Sunday, November 22, 2026

The Nerve That Could Transform Medicine

 

Interview: The Nerve That Could Transform Medicine

October 30, 2026 by Sara Talpos

The vagus nerve looks like a long white string that begins in the brainstem and travels down through the neck into the chest, where it branches to organs including the heart and lungs, and down into the abdomen, where it connects with the digestive tract. The nerve communicates through electrical signals that regulate heart rate and breathing, encourage digestion, and generally help the body maintain its normal resting state.

As it turns out, the vagus nerve can also communicate with the immune system, quieting the white blood cells that drive harmful inflammation in conditions like rheumatoid arthritis.

It’s “a really beautiful scenario,” said Kevin Tracey, a researcher and neurosurgeon whose team discovered the vagus’ link to the immune system more than two decades ago. Currently, patients with rheumatoid arthritis are prescribed drugs to treat their inflammation, Tracey said in a recent interview with Undark. But these medications don’t work for everyone, and they can cause intolerable side effects while, in some cases, costing the health care system $50,000 to $100,000 a year.

In 2007, Tracey co-founded a company, SetPoint Medical, that developed an electrical device that can be implanted on the vagus nerve in the neck. The idea was that it might offer some patients an alternative to drugs. Last year, the device was approved and this year, a study commissioned by SetPoint found that the device is “highly cost-effective” as a rheumatoid arthritis treatment in the United States.

To date, most of the data behind electrical stimulation as a possible treatment for autoimmune diseases has come from experimental animals, said Matthijs Kox, an expert in inflammation at Radboud University Medical Center in the Netherlands who is not affiliated with SetPoint. The pivotal study supporting approval of SetPoint’s device, he said, has advanced the field by showing the approach is feasible and effective in humans.

Tracey is president of the Feinstein Institutes for Medical Research and is named as an inventor on more than 100 U.S. patents, including some related to the vagus nerve stimulator. He now serves as a consultant to SetPoint Medical and is the author of “The Great Nerve,” a new book that describes the device and the science behind it. This interview took place over Zoom and has been edited for length and clarity.

Undark: What does the implantation of this stimulator entail, and who is a good candidate for it?

Kevin Tracey: Let me tell you who the candidate is first because that's really important. Under FDA approval or guidelines today, the candidates for this are patients with rheumatoid arthritis who are not having a therapeutic response from the drugs available to them, or [who] are not able to tolerate the side effects of those drugs.

The device is the size of a Tylenol capsule or a fish oil pill. And in that device — in that little, teeny thing — is a battery; the leads, which have the stimulator that goes on the vagus nerve; and an antenna that communicates to a doctor's iPad. The device is implanted on the vagus nerve. Then a [silicone] pod wraps around the device to hold it in place.

It's a general anesthesia. It's come in in the morning and go home in the afternoon. Procedure takes about an hour, give or take, and [the device] is implanted by neurosurgeons. Last I heard, it's being done now in about 40 or 45 centers in the United States under this FDA approval. Medicare has authorized payment for it, and commercial insurance companies are also beginning to authorize payment for this, which of course is a critical step.

UD: A review of your book in Science was a bit sober. It said the device's benefits are modest, and in the pivotal human study, just over a third of patients experienced the benefits, and a quarter of the patients in the control group experienced similar improvement. Is this a fair characterization in your view?

KT: There's a couple of things they left out of that story. Let's start with the patients because that's what matters to me. The study design was calling for 250 patients, give or take. They ended up with 242 in dozens of sites. Guess how many patients tried to enroll in the study?

UD: How many?

KT: How many patients went on the portal and tried to apply to be included in an experimental surgery trial of a device they didn't know worked?

UD: I'm curious — you tell me!

KT: Thirty thousand. From the perspective of a patient who's out of therapeutic options, what I read into that is: “I want to try this. I want the option.”

So, what happened in that trial? Well, the first thing is the trial hit its primary endpoint [at three months].

A couple of things were really interesting about what happened next. In the drug world, most of the response rates occur in the first three months for rheumatoid arthritis. The drug benefits tend to plateau in almost every case within three months. What happens with the SetPoint system is patients continue to improve for a year. So the benefit was slower in onset, but continued to improve for a year.

The real question is “six months later, in the people who were out of options, what percentage of them would recommend this therapy to their family members and friends? And what percentage of them responded yes?”

Ninety-four percent. It's a great rate.

Now, was everyone cured? Of course not. No one's saying that. I'm not saying that. I'm not selling anything here. And neither are my colleagues who've done the work on this. But about half of all study participants had a really dramatic response. I've met a lot of them, and every time I meet a patient who tells me she can dance at her daughter's wedding when she couldn't even button her blouse before the surgery, it brings tears to your eyes. Sometimes she cries, sometimes I cry, sometimes we both cry.

UD: If someone takes too much of a drug, say Ozempic or Tylenol, they can experience toxicity or bad side effects. Is it possible to overstimulate the vagus nerve, and if so, what happens?

KT: That's a very interesting comment that requires first a specification on how this works. This device delivers current into the vagus nerve for one minute a day, and the amount of current it delivers is on the order of 400 microamps. Many of the patients have their device programmed to go at 4:30 in the morning, and they sleep right through it. Some patients wake up to a little tingling in their neck for one minute.

We know that that is safe because there is a 30-year experience using a different device, but it's still a vagus nerve stimulator. That device is used to treat epilepsy or depression under FDA approval.

Those patients will sometimes experience a twitching of their lip or their neck. They will sometimes have a buzzing in their vocal cords when they're speaking. Some will experience pain. [Editor’s note: Vocal cord issues and pain are also potential side effects of the SetPoint device.]

Most importantly, we know from decades of experience and hundreds of thousands of patients, there's no evidence of immunosuppression. There's no black box warning. There's no evidence of increased risk of lethal sepsis or cancer or tuberculosis — all of which can be found on labels for the drugs that are currently used to treat rheumatoid arthritis.

You can make a very strong case, and I have, that vagus nerve stimulation therapy — we already have evidence — that it's safer than the current standard drugs to treat rheumatoid arthritis.

UD: I don't want to take this in a direction that I hadn't planned, but I am very curious about how this works in the world of regulation. Would this ever become a first line therapy, and what would it take for that?

KT: Dive into this! Now we're waxing out of the scientific mechanism world into a whole new universe.

Look, I personally have no criticism of what the FDA approach to this has been. They've been great. The next step is not regulatory. The next step is payers — payer behavior, paying for this — and physicians adopting a new approach to treating their patients. This is a pioneering idea. This requires rheumatologists collaborating with neurosurgeons.

There are books on this: It requires that the early adopters generate the widespread enthusiasm for the effectiveness and safety of something. It requires patients asking for it, and it requires payers paying for it, and eventually the laggards who are resistant to new — that's what they're called, the laggards —

UD: What about "people who just want more evidence"?

KT: Yes, but in the textbooks on adoption of innovation, and there are textbooks on adoption of innovation, you have the early adopters, and you have the laggards. They're not bad people. They want assurance that this isn't a flash in the pan. And they want the evidence. Ultimately that comes when the medical societies of the relevant body start to put it on their therapeutic recommendations and guidelines. Until these kinds of new ideas get on the guidelines, you're going to have the early adopters drive the story.

This article was originally published on Undark. Read the original article.

Thursday, November 5, 2026

Does the Mind Obey the Laws of Matter?



Large language models now write essays, pass exams, and hold conversations that feel uncannily human. That raises an age-old question: could a machine be conscious? Is any machine conscious already? To answer this question, we must know what consciousness is. Given the fast pace of progress in the AI race, this question is increasingly important.

Understanding consciousness also matters to stem the tide and heal the increasing frequency of mental diseases. This age-old question is also philosophical, offering new insight into our own minds and those of our fellow animals.

This newsletter and my new book, The Fermionic Mind, approach the question from an unusual direction. Instead of starting with the brain, I start with physics.

The idea that mind and matter mirror each other is not new. Aristotle wrote about the soul in the same breath as motion and change. In the twentieth century, Wolfgang Pauli—the physicist who discovered the exclusion principle—spent years exchanging letters with Carl Jung about the hidden parallels between physics and the psyche.

My starting point is simple. Physics supplies the foundations of chemistry, biology, geology, and astronomy. If consciousness is part of nature, it should be explicable in physical terms too. Just as “life” turned out to be extraordinarily organized chemistry, consciousness may be an extraordinary form of physical organization. On this view, the subjective feel of experience could be that physical process seen from the inside.

You can read the rest of the essay on Substack, the new home for my work. You will find essays an reporting about my upcoming book and other professional news. 

Thank you for your support!




Wednesday, March 11, 2026

Is major depressive disorder a disease of energy?








The brainstem’s fast, automatic perception supports our intuition. When connections between the brainstem and other brain regions, especially the frontal cortex, are weakened, long-term thinking suffers. Without a sense of the future, attention remains in the past (Belmans et al., 2023), engendering feelings of guilt and regret. Focusing on the past makes it harder to remember positive memories, creating a harmful cycle. This hopelessness is one of the main signs of depression. 

According to the World Health Organization, depression is the leading cause of global disability, affecting about 4% of the world’s population. Despite many comforts offered by modern life, genuine community bonds that can serve as a buffer against mental health struggles are often missing. Broader societal issues, such as rapid technological progress, can paradoxically separate people. As human life becomes dominated by technology, life can feel fragmented, lacking purpose and meaning. Without a sense of purpose, parents often struggle to guide their children. Consequently, depression frequently starts early; childhood stress increases the risk of depression later in life. 

The loss of control or mental stagnation makes individuals more prone to depression. Workers, pushed into micromanaged roles, miss the bigger picture. Depression is a powerless state, causing mental rigidity. Rigidity consumes energy, further draining mental resources and increasing vulnerability. This loss of mental energy was confirmed by Chinese scientists. Yuanxi Li and his colleagues found that major depressive disorder is linked to decreased overall neural energy use and lower efficiency in key circuits, especially in the prefrontal cortex. 

Telling someone with depression, “Just get over it,” is like asking a desert for water. When mental energy is depleted, the inner clock halts. In a cruel twist, the fragile mind bears the heavy weight of its past. Problems like low self-esteem and distorted social comparisons foster a sense of separation. Like a black hole, the self becomes isolated from the world. 

Healing comes from light, not darkness. Openness sheds light on our shortcomings, pain, and distress. Neural energy approaches might offer new biomarkers and mechanistic insights into depression and enhance neuromodulation-based treatments. Mindfulness-based interventions, cognitive-behavioral therapy, medications, and newer methods like neurofeedback are traditional treatment options. Combining these strategies and tailoring them to individual needs may yield the best results. 

Illustration: Automat by Edward Hopper,  1927

Discover more about consciousness by ordering my book, "Emotional Reasoning: Insight into the Conscious Experience."


Copyright © 2026 by Eva Deli

Sunday, March 1, 2026

How close are we to true AI?

 


Understanding consciousness is the ultimate prize for creators of artificial intelligence. Nevertheless, consciousness theory will also shape how we view ourselves and our place in the world. Although AI systems can mimic human reasoning, they can only regurgitate the input data. They are sophisticated pattern recognizers and content remixers, but cannot step beyond the limitations of the input. Understanding consciousness would enable us to transition from synthetic to synthesis, unlocking unlimited potential.

Computer scientists hope that recurrent computation will somehow 'awaken' code to consciousness. Yet the spectacular achievements of large language and diffusion models have not moved beyond imitation. We train models on the outputs of consciousness—our language, our art, our logic—while remaining entirely ignorant of the process that produces them. An AI can write a gut-wrenching paragraph about sadness by replicating patterns, vocabulary, and syntax. But it knows nothing of grief. It can create a shadow play, yet knows nothing of the object that casts it. This imitation, while impressive, should not be mistaken for a proper understanding of consciousness. No amount of coloring can turn the shadow into a solid object.

To reverse-engineer the mind, we need a blueprint. The pressing need to advance AI is a physicalist theory of consciousness, the architecture of subjective experience itself. The Fermionic Mind Hypothesis (FMH) is such a physicalist framework. It posits that selfhood is structurally and functionally analogous to a fermion in physics. The self's persistent core operates as an energy-regulating system, maintaining mental equilibrium through continuous thermodynamic cycles. Within this cycle, cognitive processes such as decision-making are wave-particle transitions that capture the inherent nondeterminism and contextual collapse of probabilistic mental states.

#AI #Consciousness 


Discover more about consciousness by ordering my book, "Emotional Reasoning: Insight into the Conscious Experience."


Copyright © 2026 by Eva Deli

Sunday, January 25, 2026

The Mind as a Particle: The Fermionic Mind Hypothesis

 




The Fermionic Mind Hypothesis is not a complex codename for the mind, but a way to explain its many facets: the power of emotions and how the same stimulus can lead to either stress or spiritual growth. By understanding the physics of the mind, we can become masters of our destiny. 

To understand this new theory, we have to break two common misconceptions.

Misconception #1: We are totally in control.

The mind is a particle—like an electron—and it is regulated by its environment. Imagine an electron moving through a magnetic field. The electron doesn't decide where to go; the field pushes and pulls it, guiding its path. In the same way, our mind is influenced by the 'fields' around us: our home, our job, our stress levels, and our society. Recognizing this can empower you to understand how your environment shapes your thoughts and behaviors.

Pressure and heat increase the speed of the electrons, while expansion and cold reduce it. Likewise, we often respond to external pressure with anxiety. Our heart rate and blood pressure go up. In contrast, we respond to beauty and order by calming down. We literally slow down. Both of these conditions reorganize the brain. Anxiety pushes us toward uncertainty, while beauty and order allow us to grow and mature. 

So, if we are just passive particles being pushed around by life, why are people from all walks of life able to pursue their dreams? Why do we learn? How can we strive to reach our goals? Our brain cannot change the incoming sensory information, but we can change how we manage it. Acceptance allows the mind to become calm despite a stressful environment. Moreover, it allows the brain to reorganize itself and become more resistant to stress. In this view, wisdom is the physical result of your brain regulating its stress response. 

Intellectual growth is a survival mechanism in a chaotic world, and understanding this can motivate you to pursue growth despite external pressures.

Misconception #2: We have Free Will. 

Philosophers have argued for centuries about "Free Will" vs. "Determinism." We do not control our environment. Instead, our environment regulates us. We are pushed and pulled by our history, our upbringing (the "fields" we grew up in). Thus, trying to change bad habits requires overcoming the inertia of your own mind. The ancient Stoics and Buddhists were right: We cannot control our environment, but we can control how we process the information it provides. 

This theory tells us we aren't the "kings" of the universe, as we thought we were. We are smaller, yet more connected. We are not just observers. We are active participants in this grand physics experiment. And if we understand its rules, we can become the masters of our world.


Discover more about consciousness by ordering my book, "Emotional Reasoning: Insight into the Conscious Experience."


Copyright © 2026 by Eva Deli

Thursday, December 11, 2025

What is Psychological Spin? An emotional connection




Some days you might feel focused, creative, and ready to tackle the future, while other days you're stuck ruminating on past regrets and feeling drained. The answer to that question might lie in psychological spin. This concept proposes that our emotional state is governed by a thermodynamic cycle, much like an engine, and the direction of that cycle determines our overall attitude and functioning.

At its core, your brain is a thermodynamic system that constantly exchanges information with the environment through your senses. The brain's resting state is a state of inactivity, a kind of ground state of consciousness—the source of your sense of self. To maintain this stability, emotions act as homeostatic master regulators, continuously measuring and motivating the recovery of your psychological equilibrium. When your balance is disrupted—whether by hunger or even winning a competition—emotions drive actions to restore that unique psychological state. 

When you experience a stimulus and formulate a response, your cognition runs through a closed, reversible thermodynamic cycle. The direction of this cycle is what the sources refer to as psychological spin. The cycle direction represents a discrete energy direction that shapes your attitude.

Up Spin: Mental Growth and Optimism:
The healthy, energy-absorbing direction is the Up Spin, analogous to the reversed cycle (an endothermic process). This cycle absorbs energy and entropy from the environment, fueling mental growth and intellect. This positive state requires external support or mental effort and attentional focus. It leads to a high-entropy resting state, which in turn supports high degrees of freedom, fluid intelligence, creativity, and future focus. Optimism reinforces the endothermic cycle through a self-predisposing process, supporting confidence and meaning-making.

Down Spin: Energy Drain, such as Stress and Regret:
The Down Spin is an energy-wasting cycle that represents an exothermic process. Triggered by stress, tiredness, or a lack of preparation, this cycle dumps energy and entropy onto the environment. The accumulation of unprocessed information reduces the degrees of freedom in your mind, leading to cognitive impairment. These mental states create a low-entropy resting state, introducing past focus, regret, remorse, and aggravation. The wasteful energy use of this state is highly corrosive to mental welfare, and it is associated with mental diseases having a potential thermodynamic origin.

The need for personal space and the formation of hierarchical social structures can be explained by applying the Pauli exclusion principle to consciousness. Stress, which acts like time pressure, can trigger contradictory tendencies that lead to competition and increasing inequality. Therefore, psychological spin extends beyond the individual, impacting social structures and interactions. The fear-based, insecure orientation resulting from Down Spin often requires a defensive or conflict-seeking stance, leading to polarization and social divergence. Conversely, healthy Up Spin permits social convergence.

Understanding Psychological Spin is recognizing that your attitude determines the thermodynamic directionality of your mind. Just as a compass dictates direction, your emotional direction—your spin—guides your mental progress, social behavior, and overall well-being.


Discover more about consciousness by ordering my book, "Emotional Reasoning: Insight into the Conscious Experience."
Routledge Home




Copyright © 2025 by Eva Deli

Monday, November 17, 2025

Why Our Feelings Follow the Laws of Physics

 


Did it ever occur to you that your sense of your emotional state has changed just by glancing at an object or a person? Where did that sudden, intense shift in your feelings come from? The answer, according to a new theory called the Fermionic Mind Hypothesis (FMH), might be how the simple, fundamental laws of physics act on your complicated life history. These are the same rules that govern tiny particles.

Forget the idea that your brain is just a super-fast computer. The FMH suggests that your "self" is more like a fermion (a type of subatomic particle, such as an electron). The defining trait of this mental particle? Its primary goal isn't calculation; it's balance—what scientists call a "high-entropy, restful baseline."

Think of it this way: Wave of Possibility: Before you decide what to order for lunch, your mind holds a "wave" of possibilities (pizza, salad, sandwich, skipping lunch). This is the mental chaos, or superposition.

Particle of Reality: The moment you say, "I'll take the salad," that mental wave collapses into a single, concrete reality—a particle-like decision. The mind constantly moves between this chaotic possibility and settled reality to maintain its core identity.

In this theory, emotions aren't vague, complicated feelings; they are measurable energy states that signal how far your system is from its resting, balanced baseline. When something happens—good or bad—your mind has to commit energy to deal with it. The direction of this energy is Psychological Spin: a binary orientation that determines your immediate path:

"Up-Spin" (Energy-Absorbing): This is the growth-oriented state. It's when you feel excited, determined, or motivated to approach. You're absorbing energy to engage with the world, solve a problem, or build a new idea. This state provides you with energy to grow and change.

"Down-Spin" (Dissipative): This is the decay-oriented state. It's when you feel fear, avoidance, or sadness. You're using energy to pull back, protect yourself, or reduce risk. For example, you respond to criticism with antagonism. Instead of growing, you waste your energy on anger, excuses, or avoidance.

The key insight? The mind can only truly be in one spin state at a time (approach or avoidance), just like a fundamental particle.

Why sequence matters: The most mind-bending part of the FMH is how it explains mental interference. The sequence in which you absorb information changes the outcome.

Imagine your boss asks you two questions in a row: Scenario A: First, she asks about your most significant success of the month. You feel an Up-Spin (confidence). Then, she asks for a major time commitment next week. Because you are in a confident state, you say yes enthusiastically.

Scenario B: First, she asks for a major time commitment next week. You feel an immediate Down-Spin (stress/avoidance). Then, she asks about your biggest success. You feel slightly deflated, and you either decline the commitment or accept it reluctantly. We all know which scenario will lead to a more successful outcome. 

In both scenarios, the information was the same, but the order changed your emotional spin and the resulting decision. Your mind's energy state at the exact moment of commitment dictated the result.

The FMH offers a way to understand our complex, ambiguous, and sometimes "irrational" thought process as the consequence of the underlying probabilistic laws of energy.



Discover more about consciousness by ordering my book, "Emotional Reasoning: Insight into the Conscious Experience."
Routledge Home



Copyright © 2025 by Eva Deli